Many investors already have exposure to the Japanese economy’s new era, ushered in by corporate reforms and increasing integration with broader Asia. While these growth drivers apply across the market capitalization spectrum, Matthews Asia believes a compelling alpha opportunity may exist in Japan’s small-cap market.
In a company publication, they say that the potential to generate alpha by investing in Japan’s small companies is driven by multiple factors: thin sell-side research coverage, an undersize venture-capital funding environment and low correlations to other asset classes.
Thin Research Coverage
After years of lackluster equity performance and declining commission rates in Japan, many sell-side firms focused resources on a limited number of large caps in Japan, primarily those with trading volumes that justify the costs.
Geography also plays a role according to the asset manager. Most Japan-focused sell-side firms are based in Tokyo. Companies elsewhere tend to be overlooked until they reach a certain size. As a result, the universe of small-cap Japanese equities is largely uncovered by sell-side analysts, leaving the field open for active managers to find undiscovered companies with growth potential.
Of the more than 1,900 Japanese small-cap equities for which FactSet Research Systems tracks analyst coverage, 75% are not covered by any third-party sell-side research providers or have just single-analyst coverage. Compare that with the small-cap market in the U.S., where 70% of companies are covered by three or more analysts, leaving only 22% with one or zero analyst coverage. In fact, among small caps, Japan has less analyst coverage than the U.S., Western Europe or even Asia ex Japan.
«This information asymmetry creates a potential advantage for fundamental active managers, as exciting companies with underlying characteristics that can fuel long-term, sustainable growth often are overlooked by investors.» They mention.
Limited Startup Funding
Although sell-side analyst coverage of small-cap companies in Japan is thin, there is no lack of companies to cover. In fact, Japan features a steady flow of small-company listings on public exchanges. Early- and middle-stage companies—and even companies with decades of history that want to launch a new phase of rapid growth—frequently turn to public listings to raise capital, given the country’s limited scope of venture capital and startup funding.
The gap in startup funding is significant. The market capitalization of listed U.S. companies is approximately six times larger than the market capitalization of listed Japanese companies—but the disparity in venture capital is meaningfully more pronounced: Venture capital investment in the U.S. is more than 40 times greater than in Japan, as of the end of 2017. Historically, the venture-capital landscape in Japan has been constrained by several factors, including cultural and language barriers, unfavorable tax and corporate laws and a bank-centric financial system that favors conservative investment strategies.
As a meaningful number of small Japanese companies turn to public markets for funding, according to Matthews Asia, alpha-seeking investors can benefit from a wider opportunity set—and many of these small, innovative companies start small and grow bigger, rewarding investors along the way.
Low Correlations Provide Diversification Potential
Japan small-cap stocks historically have enjoyed low correlations with other major markets, creating an environment with potential for diversification and alpha generation. In terms of correlation to the S&P 500 Index, Japan small-cap stocks posted similar marks over a 10-year period as frontier markets (such as Bangladesh and Pakistan). At the same time, Japan small caps are more liquid than frontier markets—a discernible advantage for most investors. The average daily trading volume of the Tokyo Stock Exchange Mothers Index, for example, typically is $1 billion to $3 billion, eclipsing the trading volume of the frontier markets in aggregate and even surpassing markets in South Korea and India.
The Alpha Environment in Small-Cap Japan
The characteristics described above lay the groundwork for alpha generation in Japan—but have portfolio managers historically been able to capture the resulting opportunities? In any given market, one or two managers will be able to identify alpha, even in efficient markets such as the U.S.; at Matthews Asia, they hypothesize, however, that the small-cap market in Japan has a robust alpha profile for long-term investors—one in which more than a select few can potentially identify alpha.
To validate this premise, they first gathered data on average investment-manager alpha generation in Japan relative to one of the most efficient environments: U.S. Large Blend (Core). According to Morningstar investment-manager category averages, the average Japan equity manager achieved alpha far in excess of that realized in the U.S Large Blend (Core) category over the three- and five-year periods ending March 31, 2019. In fact, alpha generation was negative for the average U.S. Large Blend (Core) manager during these periods.
Next, they broadened the universe to compare alpha generation of the average Japan manager against Europe, Asia ex Japan, U.S. Large Growth and China. As illustrated below, Japan led the pack in terms of alpha generation over the five-year period and ranked third over the three-year period.
Matthews Asia believes the Japan small-cap market is a unique environment where multiple factors combine to create a fertile hunting ground for alpha. As investors ask how best to harness Japan’s growth potential during its newest economic era, they believe the country’s small companies are a key component of the answer, providing investors with a powerful opportunity to help meet long-term goals for growth.
A New Era in Japan’s Economy
Corporate reforms are resulting in improvements in governance, capital allocation and shareholder-return policies — In part, the long malaise in the Japanese market was brought about by antiquated business practices and conceptions. For decades, Japan’s corporations and their boards primarily focused on safeguarding market share, head count and influence—all while hoarding cash, at the expense of profits and shareholder returns.
Today, the landscape is markedly different. With the advent of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s economic restructuring, sweeping corporate reforms and new Corporate Governance Code, Matthews Asia sees increasing pressure from the government, investors and peers on many of Japan’s longtime laggards to abandon weak businesses, diversify their boards and put cash to work, especially through dividends and buybacks.
From a bottom-up, fundamental perspective, they are seeing important signs of change in management behavior, including more-thoughtful and productive capital allocation decisions, a long-absent focus on ROE, more engagement with investors and better shareholder-return policies. All of these should benefit investors over the long term.
Japan is increasingly integrating with broader Asia — Over the past 15 years, Japan has become more integrated with the emerging economies of Asia than ever before. This deepening integration is propelled by multiple factors, including continued economic liberalization, tech-driven productivity gains and new entrepreneurship. As a result, they see incomes continuing to rise across emerging Asia. They expect this to continue to expand the already vast middle class, which now enjoys more leisure time, more disposable income and a taste for more sophisticated products and services.
«A growing segment of Japanese companies are well-positioned to access this growth in incomes and rising productivity. Many Japanese corporations have meaningful operations in broader Asia—especially in consumer products, household products and high-quality branded consumer products—which meet the evolving demand and growing sophistication of the rising middle class in Asia. Consequently, we see a growing set of opportunities among Japanese companies that benefit from the country’s increasing integration with the rest of Asia.» Matthews Asia concludes.